What is the Rarest Squishmallow

image of rare squishmallows 2023

 tEveryone has their preferred Squishmallow to collect. For instance, my kids collect all axolotl Squishmallows. However, like other toys, some Squishmallows are considered universally rare. To discover which Squishmallows are rare, refer to the Squishmallows Rarity Scale. As of 2023, Squishmallows have a rarity indicator on their bio tags, indicating how many thousands of units exist. Find out more here about exactly what is a squishmallow.

Squishmallows Rarity Scale:

First to Market: The first 5,000 of a particular Squishmallow variety to be released.

Rare: Only 75,000 units exist, with a silver foil.

Ultra Rare: Only 50,000 units are available at select retailers, with a gold foil.

Special Edition: Only 20,000 units exist and have a holographic tag.

Select Series: Only 10,000 units exist, exclusively available on Squishmallows.com, with a new monthly release and a black tag. These elusive Squishmallows have a purple label and are part of the “Check-In Series.”

Founder’s Edition: You can’t find these plush toys in stores, only by finding a rare “Founder’s Redemption Card” in trading card packs. Use the code to get an ultra-rare, special-edition Squishmallow.



image of rare squishmallows


There are different kinds of rare Squishmallows.

Whether you have a favorite animal or love food, there’s a Squishmallow for everyone. Squishmallows come in various sizes, animals, and characters. These plush toys range from small 3.5-inch clips to large 24-inch ones. Accessories like headphones, slippers, mystery bags, trading cards, and backpacks are available. Here are some examples of the rare ones to look for.

Axolotl Squishmallows

Axolotl Squishmallows are a popular type of Squishmallow plush toy. They feature an adorable axolotl character that has become a favorite among Squishmallow collectors. Axolotls are known for their cute and quirky appearance, distinctive smiles, and soft, plush fur. The Squishmallow axolotls come in different sizes and colors, making them an excellent choice for those who love to collect and display these cuddly creatures. They are soft, squishy, and perfect for hugging, making them an excellent choice for children and adults alike. Overall, Axolotl Squishmallows are a must-have for Squishmallow fans who want to add fun and cuteness to their collection.

Cow Squishmallows

Cow Squishmallows are a fun and adorable type of Squishmallow plush toy. These cute cow characters are made with soft, huggable materials, making them an excellent choice for children and adults alike. They come in different sizes and colors, allowing collectors to choose the perfect cow Squishmallow for their collection. Cow Squishmallows are known for their charming features, sweet spots, and soft, fluffy fur. They are perfect for snuggling and make great additions to any collection. Whether you’re a cow lover or just looking for a new cuddly toy, cow Squishmallows are a great choice that will surely bring a smile, when you rub their white belly and brown body.

Frog Squishmallows

Frog Squishmallows are a popular type of Squishmallow plush toy featuring adorable frog characters. These cuddly toys come in different sizes and colors, making them perfect for collectors of all ages. Their soft, huggable material and charming features make them great for snuggling and playtime. Frog Squishmallows are an excellent choice for those who love frogs or are looking for a fun and cute plush toy. Whether you’re a fan of these amphibians or love cute and cuddly toys, frog Squishmallows are a great addition to any collection.

Hello Kitty Squishmallows

Hello Kitty gets an even cuter makeover as a series of Squishmallows. If you’re looking for rare Hello Kitty Squishmallows, your best bet is to check out Costco.


Halloween Squishmallows – Jack the black cat

Adorable Squishmallows in the form of pumpkins, ghosts, and spiders are in the collection. They also have rare seasonal squishmallows. The rarest Squishmallow is the Jack the Black Cat Squishmallow, with a limited production of only 500 units. This is why they are the rarest squishmallow because for the limited quanitity.

Disney Squishmallows

Disney fans rejoice! The Disney Squishmallows, with limited availability, offer many beloved characters, including those from “Nightmare Before Christmas,” “Finding Nemo,” Disney princesses, and classic Disney characters.

image of rare squishmallows list

Where can you Buy a Rare Squishmallow?

Limited Squishmallows can be found in stores and online in the US, Canada, and other countries. They are sold in major retailers such as Amazon, Target, Walmart, Costco, Walgreens, Five Below. Special retailers like Cracker Barrel and Claire’s also carry them. To avoid overpaying when shopping for a rare Squishmallow online, verify that the seller is the same as the website, such as “Sold and shipped by Walmart” if shopping on Walmart.com.

Amazon Squishmallows

Shopping for most Squishmallows on Amazon is convenient as you can easily find them online without having to visit various stores. Amazon also provides the option of preordering future Squishmallows, making it easy to plan and secure your collection. Amazon also offers exclusive Squishmallows such as Jaiya the Sushi Squishmallow, which are highly sought after. However, when these a rare Squishmallow become available, you must act fast as they sell out quickly, like for tiny pink mouth.

Costco Squishmallows Selection

Costco is an ideal destination to find a rare Squishmallow at a fantastic price. It offers a variety of Squishmallows, including 5-inch, 16-inch, 20-inch, and 24-inch sizes. At Costco, you can buy a 16-inch Squishmallow for just $13.99, while the same size at Target costs $17.99. Ronnie the Cow is a highly desired Squishmallow, and the 24-inch version is exclusive to Costco. You can find various Squishmallows at Costco, including Hello Kitty, pet-themed, and 5-inch mini 8-pack collections. Costco receives new Squishmallows almost every month with the release of the Costco Coupon Book. Though the Squishmallows won’t be listed in the coupon book, the day of its release marks the arrival of a substantial shipment of Squishmallows to Costco.

Walgreens Squishmallows

Walgreens is a great place to find Disney-themed Squishmallows. They often stock ultra rare for the holiday and the rarest Squishmallows – Halloween, as well. You can buy the rarest Squishmallow at Walgreens in stores and online, but keep in mind that the prices per size may be higher than other retailers.

Five Below Squishmallows

Every week, Five Below unveils new Squishmallows releases, which can be found in stores and online. In stores, they become available at 10 a.m., while online they can be purchased at 5 a.m. ET. Keep an eye on the Five Below Facebook page to get a preview. It’s a great store because they will not be expensive squishmallows. At Five Below, you can find a variety of Squishmallow products, including small and medium-sized plushes, headphones, trading cards, and mystery blind bags.

Target Squishmallows

Target usually gets shipments of the rarest squishmallows every few weeks, so check back in the toy department, but they can often be expensive squishmallows.

Walmart Squishmallows

For the most budget-friendly option, consider purchasing your Squishmallows at Walmart. They offer great prices and even have holiday-exclusive Squishmallows available in both stores and online. However, be aware of inflated prices from third-party sellers when shopping online.

How much does rare a Squishmallow cost?

The cost of Squishmallows can vary based on where you buy them. Retail prices tend to be consistent, but when you shop with third-party sellers such as Mercari or Facebook Marketplace, the cost can be higher than retail. It’s helpful to keep in mind these general price ranges when shopping.


If you are looking to find out more about the squishmallow craze, you can read all about the squishmallow sizes. Keep your eye out for the rarest squishmallows of all – Jack the black cat and you never know when you might get lucky. Also, look for the first limited edition squishmallow collection and you can also take a look at a squishmallow auction for a limited squishmallow.


Looking for More Information – Find out more here at Fully Home

Did you find this post helpful?

You can buy me a virtual coffee to help support my site’s running cost and write more articles.

Scroll to Top